Wed, March 31, 2004
The news photos of Hussam Abdo, the boy suicide-bomber caught while trying to cross into Israel from the West Bank, speak volumes for the descent of a people into insanity.
Hussam is of an undetermined age, between 14 and 16 years old, but reputedly with the intelligence of someone younger. His face reveals the anguish of a child robbed of his innocence, not only by the weight of an armed occupation, but also by adults making him into a breathing weapon of death.
The question that emerges from Hussam's pictures is, can such depravity be explained?
The short answer is, no.
There is no collective experience anywhere that warrants, and justifies, such abuse of the young, the innocent and the gullible by scheming adults.
There have been occupations of lands in other instances, and resistance to occupation. People have fought wars for their freedom. There are situations where people still remain under occupation, as are Tibetans under the rule of Communist China. But none of this history bears relevance in explaining militant Palestinian behaviour.
It is generally accepted that the circumstances of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are most complex, and will demand an ingenious effort to end it by meeting the needs of both people.
It must also be said that no other people in modern times -- except for Jews given their history of survival against the most diabolical effort to exterminate them -- have received as much worldwide attention and support for their freedom as have Palestinians.
But no other people have abused such support, or so effectively called into question the means and ends of their struggle for freedom from occupation as have Palestinians.
The sort of thinking that rationalizes the evil of making Hussam Abdo a walking bomb, bringing death to unwary and innocent people engaged in daily chores, is, at one level,
inexplicable and, on another, densely layered between a pathology of tribal politics and religious fanaticism.
We are indebted to George Orwell in our understanding of how corruption of language lies at the basis of corrupt and life-denying politics.
In the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, it is scarcely credible anymore, particularly since 9/11, to insist that Israeli occupation of Palestinian lands is sufficient explanation for corrupt Palestinian politics.
A large part of the explanation lies in the corruption of language and its deliberate misuse for demagogic purposes.
When a people celebrate death as living and revere as a spiritual leader an individual who spews hate, condones suicide-bombing as an instrument of martyrdom and pulverizes the teachings of a transcendent faith for tribal politics, then language has been so distorted that words no longer convey established meaning.
In the Orwellian language of Palestinian politics, peace, justice, international law and other such terms mean the opposite, or what serves the purpose of not only undoing the occupation, but also eliminating Israel.
There is, however, one certainty conveyed by Hussam Abdo's pictures as he readily surrendered to Israeli soldiers.
Many Palestinians deeply long for someone to save them from their distress, and they will privately admit it has been largely of their own making.
The tragic irony here is that those who can save the Palestinians, Israelis and Americans, have the least influence on them and their leaders.
And those who cause the most harm to Palestinians also possess the most influence in their midst.
The United Nations, for instance, is a modern collective version of Pontius Pilate, asking what is truth when its Afro-Asian majority regularly mutilates the enshrined principles of its charter.
Hence the ineffectiveness of the UN -- given its undisguised partisanship in favour of Palestinian rights without due consideration of Israeli interests -- in resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
It is for Palestinians to recognize where insanity has brought them and then, as Hussam Abdo did, choose life and with it a just peace they deserve.
In the end, it will be for Americans to take abuse of the UN's Afro-Asian majority, along with that of their Western supporters, and bring an end to this now century-old conflict.
Photos of boy suicide-bomber reveal horrid truth
By SALIM MANSUR
The news photos of Hussam Abdo, the boy suicide-bomber caught while trying to cross into Israel from the West Bank, speak volumes for the descent of a people into insanity.
Hussam is of an undetermined age, between 14 and 16 years old, but reputedly with the intelligence of someone younger. His face reveals the anguish of a child robbed of his innocence, not only by the weight of an armed occupation, but also by adults making him into a breathing weapon of death.
The question that emerges from Hussam's pictures is, can such depravity be explained?
The short answer is, no.
There is no collective experience anywhere that warrants, and justifies, such abuse of the young, the innocent and the gullible by scheming adults.
There have been occupations of lands in other instances, and resistance to occupation. People have fought wars for their freedom. There are situations where people still remain under occupation, as are Tibetans under the rule of Communist China. But none of this history bears relevance in explaining militant Palestinian behaviour.
It is generally accepted that the circumstances of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are most complex, and will demand an ingenious effort to end it by meeting the needs of both people.
It must also be said that no other people in modern times -- except for Jews given their history of survival against the most diabolical effort to exterminate them -- have received as much worldwide attention and support for their freedom as have Palestinians.
But no other people have abused such support, or so effectively called into question the means and ends of their struggle for freedom from occupation as have Palestinians.
The sort of thinking that rationalizes the evil of making Hussam Abdo a walking bomb, bringing death to unwary and innocent people engaged in daily chores, is, at one level,
inexplicable and, on another, densely layered between a pathology of tribal politics and religious fanaticism.
We are indebted to George Orwell in our understanding of how corruption of language lies at the basis of corrupt and life-denying politics.
In the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, it is scarcely credible anymore, particularly since 9/11, to insist that Israeli occupation of Palestinian lands is sufficient explanation for corrupt Palestinian politics.
A large part of the explanation lies in the corruption of language and its deliberate misuse for demagogic purposes.
When a people celebrate death as living and revere as a spiritual leader an individual who spews hate, condones suicide-bombing as an instrument of martyrdom and pulverizes the teachings of a transcendent faith for tribal politics, then language has been so distorted that words no longer convey established meaning.
In the Orwellian language of Palestinian politics, peace, justice, international law and other such terms mean the opposite, or what serves the purpose of not only undoing the occupation, but also eliminating Israel.
There is, however, one certainty conveyed by Hussam Abdo's pictures as he readily surrendered to Israeli soldiers.
Many Palestinians deeply long for someone to save them from their distress, and they will privately admit it has been largely of their own making.
The tragic irony here is that those who can save the Palestinians, Israelis and Americans, have the least influence on them and their leaders.
And those who cause the most harm to Palestinians also possess the most influence in their midst.
The United Nations, for instance, is a modern collective version of Pontius Pilate, asking what is truth when its Afro-Asian majority regularly mutilates the enshrined principles of its charter.
Hence the ineffectiveness of the UN -- given its undisguised partisanship in favour of Palestinian rights without due consideration of Israeli interests -- in resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
It is for Palestinians to recognize where insanity has brought them and then, as Hussam Abdo did, choose life and with it a just peace they deserve.
In the end, it will be for Americans to take abuse of the UN's Afro-Asian majority, along with that of their Western supporters, and bring an end to this now century-old conflict.